Abstract The Drosophila intrinsically disordered protein Ultrabithorax (Ubx) undergoes a series of phase transitions, beginning with noncovalent interactions between apparently randomly organized monomers, and evolving over time to form increasingly ordered coacervates. This assembly process ends when specific dityrosine covalent bonds lock the monomers in place, forming macroscale materials. Inspired by this hierarchical, multistep assembly process, we analyzed the impact of protein concentration, assembly time, and subphase composition on the early, noncovalent stages of Ubx assembly, which are extremely sensitive to their environment. We discovered that in low salt buffers, we can generate a new type of Ubx material from early coacervates using 5‐fold less protein, and 100‐fold less assembly time. Comparison of the new materials with standard Ubx fibers also revealed differences in the extent of wrinkling on the fiber surface. A new image analysis technique based on autocorrelation of scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images was developed to quantify these structural differences. These differences extend to the molecular level: new materials form more dityrosine covalent cross‐links per monomer, but without requiring the specific tyrosine residues necessary for crosslinking previously established materials. We conclude that varying the assembly conditions represents a facile and inexpensive process for creating new materials. Most new biopolymers are created by changing the composition of the monomers or the method used to drive assembly. In contrast, in this study we used the same monomers and assembly approach, but altered the assembly time and chemical environment to create a new material with unique properties.